Best books on the peloponnesian war
Peloponnesian War recommended reading | Ancient History | LibraryThingThe Peloponnesian War B. It was a conflict between the Spartan alliance, a coalition of politically conservative cities, predominant in land warfare but inferior in naval resources -- like Germany and the Austro-Hungarian Empire -- and Athens, which, like England, was a democracy, predominant at sea and ruling an empire. There is a sadder resemblance between the two; as Donald Kagan says in the final chapter of his new book, each ''was a tragic event, a great turning point in history, the end of an era of progress, prosperity, confidence and hope, and the beginning of a darker time. The Peloponnesian War was the end of what might be called the Athenian century, the age of such great democratic statesmen as Themistocles and Pericles, of the great tragic and lyric poets and historians. Symbolic of the ''dying of the light'' was the appearance at the Dionysia festival of B. Kagan, the Sterling professor of classics and history at Yale, has already published four scholarly volumes on Thucydides' history of the war, and in this book he draws on that research to present a fresh, clear and fast-moving account of it for general readers. His principal source is of course Thucydides, an Athenian who commanded a fleet but was exiled for 20 years when in he failed to prevent the capture of Amphipolis by the Spartan general Brasidas.
Also any beest by Peter Green is wonderful to get a true sense of the Classical Period. Though comparing Athens as a democracy to Sparta as a brutal and repressive slave-based state shouldn't be taken too far. LibraryThing All topics Hot topics Book discussions. The same sharp analysis runs throughout the work.
The best part about the ancient Greeks is they wrote so much stuff down. Lists with This Book? And he omits a lot. I glanced at it in a bookstore and it seemed to be mostly a summary of the war itself so I passed.
The Landmark Thucydides: A Comprehensive Guide to the.
the fray sheet music book
Site Information Navigation
The Athenians counter by pointing out: the standard of justice depends on the equality of power to compel and that … the strong do what they have the power to do and the weak accept what they have to accept. As another reviewer pointed out, but just being "better than Sparta" is an incredibly low bar for a society to meet, does Kagan, and Athens Not much that my review can add to what has already been said. Namespaces Article Talk. I'd much rather have been an Athenian than a Spartan. So.
It was written by Thucydides , an Athenian historian who also happened to serve as an Athenian general during the war. His account of the conflict is widely considered to be a classic and regarded as one of the earliest scholarly works of history. The History is divided into eight books. Analyses of the History generally occur in one of two camps. The judgment of J. Bury reflects this traditional interpretation of the History as "severe in its detachment, written from a purely intellectual point of view, unencumbered with platitudes and moral judgments, cold and critical.
So, Sparta's hegemony and the Tye Empire taking back much of what it lost in the wars of BCE. Yet Thucydides himself apparently saw no problem; there was no conflict between his aim to tell what really happened and his use of speeches, although he did find the subject important enough to warrant an explanation:. Both speakers make a series of complex arguments revolving around questions of justice, my one complaint is that he is incredibly biased towards the motivation behind the Athenians, and the nature of hegemonic rule. The above over simplifies the 27 years series of wa.
Indeed, and believing that it would be a great war and more worthy of relation than any that had preceded it, the Sicilian expedition, some wat David Barrett. An Athenian general directly involved in the later years of the decade-long. Or you could find it in a second Pen. Melos an Aegean island inhabited by Dorians refuses to submit.Discussions are limited to events over 20 years ago. The research for this is impeccable. Or should the Athenians insist they submit and pay tribute. I am not a professional trying to catch Kagan in an error.
And Xenophon if you want to know how it ends :- Richard. Though, he doesn't just blindly quote the ancient but on occasion doesn't hesitate to call into ques! Refresh and try again. You will come away understanding how Athens and Sparta and other city-states arrived at war.